Court Roll (3)
Unpublished
FEB/MAR 2018
Wednesday: 14 February 2018
COURT A
1. H Ras v The State - 1207/2017 (GP)
Judges: Leach JA, Van der Merwe JA, Mocumie JA
Thursday: 15 February 2018
COURT A
2. Sohahle Macinezela (aka Macimela) v The State- 550/2017 (ECM)
Judges: Navsa JA, Majiedt JA, Dambuza JA, Mocumie JA, Hughes AJA
AND
3. Lonwabo Tete v The State - 663/2017 (ECG)
Judges: Navsa JA, Majiedt JA, Dambuza JA, Mocumie JA, Hughes AJA
COURT B
4. The State v Noel Chauke & another - 826/2017 (GJ)
Judges: Lewis JA, Seriti JA, Saldulker JA, Van der Merwe JA, Makgoka AJA
AND
5. Sente Joseph Thakeli & another v The State - 231/2017 (FB)
Judges: Lewis JA, Seriti JA, Saldulker JA, Van der Merwe JA, Makgoka AJA
COURT C
6. The Director of Public Prosecutions, Eastern Cape (Grahamstown) v Winston Booysen - 580/2017 (ECG)
Judges: Bosielo JA, Wallis JA, Pillay D AJA
AND
7. Patrick Vusumuzi Ngcobo v The State - 1344/2016 (KZP)
Judges: Bosielo JA, Wallis JA, Pillay D AJA
Friday: 16 February 2018
COURT A
8. The Director of Public Prosecutions, Eastern Cape (Grahamstown) v Willie Themba Yoyo - 581/2017 (ECG)
Judges: Maya P, Swain JA, Mbha JA, Mothle JA, Hughes AJA
AND
9. The Director of Public Prosecutions, Eastern Cape (Grahamstown) v Mzukisi Peli - 533/2017(ECG)
Judges: Maya P, Swain JA, Mbha JA, Mothle AJA, Hughes AJA
COURT B
10. Tebogo Patrick Ledwaba Phetoe v The State - 1361/2016 (GJ)
Judges: Shongwe ADP, Leach JA, Mocumie JA, Plasket AJA , Pillay D AJA
COURT C
11. Thengimpilo Maqebhula v The State- 284/2017 (ECG)
Judges: Ponnan JA, Willis JA, Mathopo JA, Davis AJA, Rogers AJA
Monday: 19 February 2018
COURT A
12. Johannes van den Heever v Louis Marius Taljaard NO & others - 289/2017 (GP)
Judges: Navsa JA, Bosielo JA, Leach JA, Mocumie JA, Makgoka AJA
COURT B
13. Waymark Infotech (Pty) Ltd v Road Traffic Management Corporation - 440/2017 (GP)
Judges: Lewis JA, Seriti JA, Mathopo JA, Davis AJA, Plasket AJA
COURT C
14. Auction Alliance (Pty) Ltd v Wade Park (Pty) Ltd- 342/2016 (KZP)
Judges: Ponnan JA, Majiedt JA, Swain JA, Dambuza JA, Mothle AJA
Tuesday: 20 February 2018
COURT A
15. The Director-General, Department of Home Affairs & another v Nurul Islam & others - 459/2017 (WCC)
Judges: Maya P, Majiedt JA, Mbha JA, Van der Merwe JA, Rogers AJA
COURT B
16. Ocean Echo Properties 327 CC & another v Old Mutual Life Assurance Company (South Africa) Ltd
288/2017 (WCC)
Judges: Ponnan JA, Willis JA, Saldulker JA, Mothle AJA, Hughes AJA
COURT C
17. Anton Loggenberg NO & others v Nicolaas Petrus Maree - 286/2017 (FB)
Judges: Bosielo JA, Seriti JA, Wallis JA, Swain JA, Pillay D AJA
Wednesday : 21 February 2018
COURT A
18. Christopher Fortuin v The State- 838/2017 (GP)
Judges: Shongwe ADP, Saldulker JA, Dambuza JA, Van der Merwe JA, Pillay D AJA
COURT B
19. Road Accident Fund v Mogamat Ridaa Abrahams - 276/2017 (WCC)
Judges: Navsa JA, Lewis JA, Willis JA, Makgoka AJA, Hughes AJA
COURT C
20. Tshamuhau Maphaha & another v The State - 174/2017 (GJ)
Judges: Leach JA, Mbha JA, Mocumie JA, Plasket AJA, Mothle AJA
Thursday: 22 February 2018
COURT A
21. The Director of Home Affairs & others v Ntumba Guella Nbaya & others
227/2017 (WCC)
Judges:Maya P, Majiedt JA, Mbha JA, Van der Merwe JA, Rogers AJA
COURT B
22. John Anthony Shaw & another v Glenn William Mackintosh & another - 267/2017 (GJ)
Judges: Shongwe ADP, Wallis JA, Dambuza JA, Mathopo JA, Davis AJA
COURT C
23. Stu Davidson and Sons (Pty) Ltd v Eastern Cape Motors (Pty) Ltd - 260/2017 (ECG)
Judges: Lewis JA, Ponnan JA, Bosielo JA, Seriti JA, Pillay D AJA
Friday: 23 February 2018
COURT A
24. John Walker Pools v Consolidated Aone Trade & Invest 6 (Pty) Ltd (in liquidation) & another - 245/2017 (KZP)
Judges: Shongwe ADP, Willis JA, Mocumie JA, Mothle AJA, Rogers AJA
COURT B
25. Patmar Explorations (Pty) Ltd & others v The Limpopo Development Tribunal & others - 1250/2016 (GP)
Judges: Navsa JA, Wallis JA, Mathopo JA, Davis AJA, Hughes AJA
COURT C
26. Mobile Telephone Networks (Pty) Ltd & another v Spilhaus Property Holdings (Pty) Ltd & others - 208/2017 (WCC)
Judges: Ponnan JA, Saldulker JA, Swain JA, Plasket AJA, Makgoka AJA
Monday: 26 February 2018
COURT A
27. Fikiswa Fesi & another v The Trustees Elect of the Ndabeni Communal Property Trust (IT1056/98)
and
Master of the Eastern Cape High Court, Cape Town & another v The Trustees Elect of the Ndabeni Communal Property Trust (IT1056/98) - 412/2017 and 411/2017 (WCC)
Judges: Navsa JA, Bosielo JA, Swain JA, Mbha JA, Pillay D AJA
COURT B
28. PG Group (Pty) Ltd & others v National Energy Regulator of South Africa & another - 150/2017 (GP)
Judges: Lewis JA, Ponnan JA, Leach JA, Davis AJA, Makgoka AJA
COURT C
29. Husband v Wife - 1224/2016 and 144/2017 (WCC)
Judges: Majiedt JA, Saldulker JA, Dambuza JA, Plasket AJA, Rogers AJA
Tuesday: 27 February 2018
COURT A
30. Pietermaritzburg and District Council for the Care of the Aged (PADCA) v Redlands Development Projects (Pty) Ltd & others- 184/2017 (KZP)
Judges: Navsa JA, Wallis JA, Willis JA, Mathopo JA, Pillay D AJA
COURT B
31. K2014/49699/07 t/a Tiekiedraai Eiendomme (Pty) Ltd v Shell South Africa Marketing (Pty) Ltd & others- 1206/2016 (GP)
Judges: Bosielo JA, Swain JA, Mbha JA, Mothle AJA, Hughes AJA
COURT C
Wednesday: 28 February 2018
COURT A
32. Dinnermates (TVL) CC v Piquante Brands International (Pty) Limited & another- 401/2017 (GP)
Judges: Maya P, Wallis JA, Mathopo JA, Davis AJA, Rogers AJA
COURT B
33. Eastern Cape Parks and Tourism Agency v Medbury (Pty) Ltd t/a Crown River Safari & another
816/2016 (ECG)
Judges: Navsa JA, Bosielo JA, Seriti JA, Saldulker JA, Swain JA
COURT C
34. Minister of Home Affairs & another v The Public Protector of the Republic of South Africa
308/2017 (GP)
Judges: Lewis JA, Majiedt JA, Willis JA, Plasket AJA, Mothle AJA
Thursday: 1 March 2018
COURT A
35. South African National Parks v MTO Forestry (Pty) Ltd & another- 446/2017 (WCC)
Judges: Navsa JA, Leach JA, Dambuza JA, Davis AJA, Rogers AJA
COURT C
36. Brompton Court Body Corporate SS 119/2006 v Christina Fundiswa Khumalo - 398/2017 (GJ)
Judges: Ponnan JA, Van der Merwe JA, Mocumie JA, Pillay D AJA, Makgoka AJA
Friday: 2 March 2018
COURT A
37. Nokulunga Primrose Sonti & another v The Minister of Justice and Correctional Services & others
and
General Alfred Moyo & another v The Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development & others
386/2017 and 387/2017 (GP)
Judges: Maya P, Wallis JA, Mbha JA, Van der Merwe JA, Makgoka AJA
COURT B
38. Ndabenhle Business Enterprises CC v Vodacom (Pty) Ltd- 441/2017 (GJ)
Judges: Shongwe ADP, Swain JA, Mocumie JA, Mothle AJA, Hughes AJA
COURT C
39. Nokuthula Nomsa Khoza obo Zamokuhle Khoza v The MEC for Health of the Gauteng Provincial Government- 216/2017 (GJ)
Judges: Lewis JA, Majiedt JA, Willis JA, Dambuza JA, Pillay D AJA
Monday: 5 March 2018
COURT A
40. Budge, Jonathan Stuart & others v Glyn-Cuthbert Russel & others- 1046/2016 (GJ)
Judges: Shongwe ADP, Willis JA, Saldulker JA, Mbha JA, Van der Merwe JA
COURT B
41. Overstrand Municipality v Water and Sanitation Services South Africa (Pty) Ltd & another - 143/2017 (WCC)
Judges: Navsa JA, Leach JA, Mocumie JA, Davis AJA, Makgoka AJA
COURT C
42. Glenn Marc Bee v The Road Accident Fund- 093/2017 (WCC)- 6 9 16 24 25
Judges:Bosielo JA, Seriti JA, Mathopo JA, Rogers AJA, Hughes AJA
Tuesday: 6 March 2018
COURT A
43. Ludidi Ludidi v Nolitha Ludidi & others - 658/2017 (ECM)
Judges: Maya P, Dambuza JA, Mathopo JA, Mocumie JA, Rogers AJA
COURT B
44. The Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service v The Executors of Estate Late Sidney Ellerine - 142/2017 (Tax Court)
Judges: Navsa JA, Wallis JA, Mbha JA, Davis AJA, Hughes AJA
COURT C
45. Bannister’s Print (Pty) Limited v D & A Calendars CC & another - 1078/2016 (GJ)
Judges:Lewis JA, Willis JA, Swain JA, Pillay D AJA, Mothle AJA
Wednesday: 7 March 2018
COURT A
46. Nomgcobo Jiba & another v The General Council of The Bar of South Africa
and
The General Council of the Bar v Sibongile Mzinyathi - 141/2017 (GP)
Judges: Shongwe ADP, Leach JA, Seriti JA, Van der Merwe JA, Mocumie JA
COURT B
COURT C
Thursday: 8 March 2018
COURT A
47. Bryan James de Klerk v Minister of Police - 329/2017 (GP)
Judges: Shongwe ADP, Leach JA, Majiedt JA, Rogers AJA, Hughes AJA
COURT B
48. Automated Office Technology (Pty) Ltd t/a AOT Finance v International Colleges Group (Pty) Ltd
385/2017 (WCC)
Judges: Navsa JA, Seriti JA, Swain JA, Pillay D AJA, Makgoka AJA
COURT C
49. Palabora Copper (Pty) Ltd v Motlokwa Transport & Construction (Pty) Ltd - 298/2017 (GP)
Judges:Bosielo JA, Wallis JA, Dambuza JA, Van der Merwe JA, Plasket AJA
Friday: 9 March 2018
COURT A
50. The Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service v Daikin Air Conditioning South Africa (Pty) Ltd - 185/2017 (GP)
Judges: Maya P, Majiedt JA, Mbha JA, Van der Merwe JA, Davis AJA
COURT B
51. Bonita Marieta Steenkamp v Pieter Steenkamp - 291/2017 (ECG)
Judges: Lewis JA, Willis JA, Swain JA, Mathopo JA, Mocumie JA
COURT C
52. Vincorp (Pty) Ltd v Trust Hungary ZRT - 61/2017 (WCC)
Judges: Ponnan JA, Bosielo JA, Saldulker JA, Plasket AJA, Mothle AJA
Monday: 12 March 2018
COURT A
53. Leonie Logie Kelbrick & others v Nelson Attorneys & another - 302/2017 (ECP)
Judges: Shongwe ADP, Wallis JA, Dambuza JA, Van der Merwe JA, Makgoka AJA
COURT B
54. The National Consumer Commission v Univision Services Association NPC & others - 618/2017 (GP)
Judges: Navsa JA, Leach JA, Seriti JA, Mocumie JA, Hughes AJA
COURT C
55. Ekhurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality v NCP Chlorchem (Pty) Ltd & others - 119/2017 (GJ)
Judges: Majiedt JA, Saldulker JA, Swain JA, Plasket AJA, Mothle AJA
Tuesday: 13 March 2018
COURT A
56. Lion Match Company (Pty) Ltd v Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service - 301/2017 (Tax Court)
Judges:Ponnan JA, Mbha JA, Dambuza JA, Mathopo JA, Davis AJA
COURT B
57. B S Nkola v Argent Steel Group (Pty) Ltd t/a Phoenix Steel - 406/2017 (ECG)
Judges: Lewis JA, Saldulker JA, Swain JA, Pillay D AJA, Makgoka AJA
COURT C
58. The Director-General for the Department of Rural Development and Land Reform & another v Bhekindlela Mwelase & others
and
Bhekindlela Mwelase & others v The Director-General for the Department of Rural Development and Land Reform & another - 306/2017 and 314/2017 (Land Claims Court)
Judges: Bosielo JA, Leach JA, Seriti JA, Willis JA, Mocumie JA
Wednesday: 14 March 2018
COURT A
COURT B
COURT C
Thursday: 15 March 2018
COURT A
59. David Carl Mostert & others v Firstrand Bank Limited t/a RMB Private Bank & another - 198/2017 (WCC)
Judges: Shongwe ADP, Bosielo JA, Van der Merwe JA, Rogers AJA, Hughes AJA
COURT B
60. The Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service v Danwet 202 (Pty) Ltd - 399/2017 (Tax Court)
Judges: Lewis JA, Majiedt JA, Mbha JA, Davis AJA, Mothle AJA
COURT C
61. BMW Financial Services (SA) (Pty) Ltd v DD Tabata - 445/2017 (GP)
Judges: Ponnan JA, Wallis JA, Willis JA, Mathopo JA, Pillay D AJA
Friday: 16 March 2018
COURT A
62. Adv A J du Toit NO obo Ntsikelelo Mafanya v Road Accident Fund - 140/2017 (WCC)
Judges: Maya P, Saldulker JA, Swain JA, Dambuza JA, Makgoka AJA
COURT B
63. Devi Rajah & another v Oreste Balduzzi - 076/2017 (GJ)
Judges: Navsa JA, Leach JA, Wallis JA, Mothle AJA, Hughes AJA
COURT C
Monday: 19 March 2018
COURT A
COURT B
COURT C
Tuesday: 20 March 2018
COURT A
COURT B
COURT C
Wednesday: 21 March 2018
PUBLIC HOLIDAY
Thursday: 22 March 2018
COURT A
COURT B
COURT C
Friday: 23 March 2018
COURT A
COURT B
COURT C
Monday: 26 March 2018
COURT A
COURT B
COURT C
Tuesday: 27 March 2018
COURT A
COURT B
COURT C
Wednesday: 28 March 2018
COURT A
COURT B
COURT C
Thursday: 29 March 2018
COURT A
COURT B
COURT C
Friday: 30 March 2018
COURT B
COURT A
COURT B
COURT C
Court Roll (4)
UnpublishedMAY 2018
Updated: 2018.03.23
Monday: 26 March 2018
COURT A
COURT B
COURT C
Tuesday: 27 March 2018
COURT A
COURT B
COURT C
Wednesday: 28 March 2018
COURT A
COURT B
COURT C
Thursday: 29 March 2018
COURT A
COURT B
COURT C
Friday: 30 March 2018
COURT B
COURT A
COURT B
COURT C
Tuesday: 01 May 2018
SHIPPING LAW SEMINAR
Wednesday: 02 May 2018
COURT A
1. President of the Republic of South Africa v Democratic Alliance & others
664/2017 (GP)
Judges: Maya P, Majiedt JA, Dambuza JA, Plasket AJA, Mothle AJA
COURT B
2. Louis Pasteur Hospital Holdings (Pty) Ltd v Bonitas Medical Fund
281/2017 (GP)
Judges: Navsa JA, Seriti JA, Saldulker JA, Makgoka AJA
COURT C
3. Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality & 5 others vs T A Thubakgale & 133 others
125/2018 (GP)
Judges: Ponnan JA, Swain JA, Mbha JA, Pillay D AJA, Hughes AJA
Thursday: 03 May 2018
COURT A
4. Director of Public Prosecutions, Free State v Sello Joseph Mashune
675/17 (FB)
Judges: Lewis JA, Dambuza JA, Rogers AJA
AND
5. The Director of Public Prosecutions: Gauteng Division, Pretoria v Funewer Coaster Hamisi
895/2017 (GP)
Judges: Lewis JA, Dambuza JA, Rogers AJA
COURT B
6. Antony Louis Mostert & others v Simon John Nash & another
604/2017 and 597/2017 (GP)
Judges: Ponnan JA, Wallis JA, Willis JA, Swain JA, Pillay D AJA
COURT C
7. Alfeus Christo Scholtz & others v The State
428/2017, 491/2017, 635/2017 & 636/2017 (NCK)
Judges: Leach JA, Mathopo JA, Van der Merwe JA, Mocumie JA, Mothle AJA
Friday: 04 May 2018
COURT A
8. Siyabonga David Gongqose & others v Minister of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries & others
and
Siyabonga David Gongqose & others v The State & others
1340/2016 and 287/2017(1365/2016) (ECM)
Judges: Maya P, Majiedt JA, Dambuza JA, Plasket AJA
COURT B
9. The Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service v K W J Investment Services (Pty) Ltd
466/2017 (Tax Court)
Judges: Navsa JA, Wallis JA, Mbha JA, Davis AJA, Makgoka AJA
COURT C
7. Alfeus Christo Scholtz & others v The State
428/2017, 491/2017, 635/2017 & 636/2017 (NCK)
Judges: Leach JA, Mathopo JA, Van der Merwe JA, Mocumie JA, Mothle AJA
Monday: 07 May 2018
COURT A
10. David Mile Osborne v Mark William Cockin N O & others
549/2017 (ECG)
Judges: Lewis JA, Willis JA, Saldulker JA, Plasket AJA, Hughes AJA
COURT B
11. The Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service v The South African Breweries (Pty) Ltd
442/2017 (GP)
Judges: Ponnan JA, Wallis JA, Dambuza JA, Davis AJA, Rogers AJA
COURT C
12. Premier Attraction 300 CC t/a Premier Security v City of Cape Town
592/2017 (WCC)
Judges: Majiedt JA, Swain JA, Mbha JA, Pillay D AJA
Tuesday: 08 May 2018
COURT A
13. Mogale City Local Municipality v Black Tad Investments CC
889/2017 (GJ)
Judges: Shongwe ADP, Mbha JA, Van der Merwe JA, Mocumie JA, Plasket AJA
COURT B
14. Orthotouch Ltd v Jurie Johannes Geldenhuys
1027/2017 (GP)
Judges: Navsa JA, Majiedt JA, Willis JA, Rogers AJA
AND
15. Nicolas Georgiou & 5 others v Sharon Ann Vlok & 3 others
1018/2017 (GP)
Judges: Navsa JA, Majiedt JA, Willis JA, Rogers AJA
COURT C
16. Novartis AG v Cipla Medpro (Pty) Ltd & another
728/2017 (GP)
Judges: Lewis JA, Ponnan JA, Leach JA, Saldulker JA, Mathopo JA
Wednesday: 09 May 2018
COURT A
17. Morris Material Handling Limited v Morris Material Handling SA (Pty) Ltd & others
829/2017 (GP)
Judges: Maya P, Majiedt JA, Wallis JA, Dambuza JA, Van der Merwe JA
COURT B
18. Douglasdale Dairy (Pty) Ltd & others v Elizabeth Ann Bragge & another 731/2017 (GJ)
Judges: Shongwe ADP, Willis JA, Swain JA, Davis AJA, Hughes AJA
COURT C
19. Earl Flanagan v The Minister of Safety & Security
497/2017 (ECP)
Judges: Lewis JA, Seriti JA, Saldulker JA, Makgoka AJA
Thursday: 10 May 2018
COURT A
20. Vasanthi Naidoo v Discovery Life Limited & others
202/2017 (GJ)
Judges: Shongwe ADP, Wallis JA, Mbha JA, Hughes AJA
COURT B
21. Jane Erasmus & others v Nelson Mandela Bay Metropolitan Municipality
537/2017 (ECP)
Judges: Navsa JA, Leach JA, Mathopo JA, Mocumie JA, Pillay D AJA
COURT C
22. Zitonix (Pty) Ltd v K2012150042 (South Africa) (Pty) Ltd
290/2017 (WCC)
Judges: Lewis JA, Swain JA, Davis AJA, Mothle AJA, Rogers AJA
Friday: 11 May 2018
COURT A
23. Friedshelf 325 (Pty) Ltd & another v Sizane Betty Mokwena
652/17 (LCC)
Judges: Maya P, Mbha JA, Van der Merwe JA, Mothle AJA
COURT B
24. The Executor of the Estate of the late Josephine Tereblanche Gouws (Charmaine Celliers N O) v Magnificent Mile Trading 30 (Pty) Ltd & others
594/2017 (GP)
Judges: Shongwe ADP, Swain JA, Dambuza JA, Plasket AJA, Rogers AJA
COURT C
25. City of Tshwane Metropolitan Municipality v Lombardy Development (Pty) Ltd & others
724/2017 (GP)
Judges: Ponnan JA, Majiedt JA, Seriti JA, Pillay D AJA, Makgoka AJA
Monday: 14 May 2018
COURT A
26. Buffalo City Metropolitan Municipality v Nurcha Development Finance (Pty) Ltd & others
378/2017 (ECE)
Judges: Shongwe ADP, Seriti JA, Willis JA, Rogers AJA
COURT B
27. Leon St Leger Bouttell v Road Accident Fund
324/2017 (GP)
Judges: Navsa JA, Majiedt JA, Mbha JA, Plasket AJA, Hughes AJA
COURT C
28. Minister of Defence & another v Bongani Postolie Xulu
337/2017 (GP)
Judges: Lewis JA, Wallis JA, Saldulker JA, Mocumie JA, Pillay D AJA
Tuesday: 15 May 2018
COURT A
29. Ntuntu David Kekana v Road Accident Fund
206/2017 (GP)
Judges: Shongwe ADP, Leach JA, Mbha JA, Pillay D AJA, Mothle AJA
COURT B
30. Lya Louw & others v Ashraf Davids & others
783/2017 (WCC)
Judges: Navsa JA, Swain JA, Davis AJA, Plasket AJA, Rogers AJA
COURT C
31. Magnum Simplex International (Pty) Ltd v The MEC Provincial Treasury, The Provincial Government of Limpopo
556/2017 (GP)
Judges: Lewis JA, Mathopo JA, Hughes AJA
Wednesday: 16 May 2018
COURT A
32. Francois Jean de Villiers & others v The Trustees for the time being of the G J N Trust & others
756/2017 (WCC)
Judges: Shongwe ADP, Seriti JA, Van der Merwe JA, Rogers AJA
COURT B
33. The Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service v JM DA Encarnacӓo N O & another
543/17 (GP)
Judges: Navsa JA, Willis JA, Mocumie JA, Davis AJA, Plasket AJA
COURT C
34. The MEC for the Department of Roads and Public Works & another v AGRI Eastern Cape & others
1107/2017 (ECG)
Judges: Ponnan JA, Wallis JA, Swain JA, Dambuza JA, Hughes AJA
Thursday: 17 May 2018
COURT A
35. WDR Earthmoving Enterprises CC & another v The Joe Gqabi District Municipality & others
392/2017 (ECG)
Judges: Navsa JA, Swain JA, Davis AJA, Pillay D AJA, Hughes AJA
COURT B
36. Bruce St.Clair Moor & another v The Tongaat-Hulett Pension Fund & others
518/2017 (KZD)
Judges: Lewis JA, Majiedt JA, Mbha JA, Dambuza JA
COURT C
37. Madibeng Local Municipality v Public Investment Corporation Ltd
603/2017 (GP)
Judges: Ponnan JA, Wallis JA, Willis JA, Plasket AJA, Makgoka AJA
Friday: 18 May 2018
COURT A
38. Road Accident Fund v Khathutshelo Gladys Masindi
586/2017 (GJ)
Judges: Shongwe ADP, Majiedt JA, Swain JA, Mocumie JA, Rogers AJA
COURT B
39. Pioneer Foods (Pty) Ltd v Minister of Finance & others
1166/2017 (WCC)
Judges: Ponnan JA, Wallis JA, Dambuza JA, Davis AJA, Mothle AJA
COURT C
40. Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality v Argent Industrial Investments (Pty) Ltd
809/2017 (GJ)
Judges: Leach JA, Seriti JA, Mbha JA, Van der Merwe JA, Makgoka AJA
Monday: 21 May 2018
COURT A
41. Netshimbupfe Fuzani Ernest & another v Mulaudzi Vhangani Cathcart (on behalf of the Netshimbupfe Royal Council) & others
563/2017 (GP)
Judges: Maya P, Dambuza JA, Mathopo JA, Van der Merwe JA, Mothle AJA
COURT B
42. Kennedy Ntsako Shiburi v The State
205/2017 (LP)
Judges: Shongwe ADP, Saldulker JA, Pillay D AJA, Makgoka AJA, Hughes AJA
COURT C
43. The Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service v Char-Trade 117 CC t/a Ace Packaging
776/2017 (Tax Court)
Judges: Navsa JA, Lewis JA, Mbha JA, Davis AJA
Tuesday: 22 May 2018
COURT A
44. Jan George Gabriel Stoltz v Prof L J S Steenkamp
127/2017 (GP)
Judges: Shongwe ADP, Majiedt JA, Saldulker JA, Rogers AJA
COURT B
45. AFGRI Operations Limited v Dipaleseng Local Municipality
708/2017 (GJ)
Judges: Navsa JA, Leach JA, Wallis JA, Mbha JA, Van der Merwe JA
COURT C
46. Mantis Investment Holdings (Pty) Ltd v Eastern Cape Development Corporation & others
857/2017 (ECP)
Judges: Ponnan JA, Swain JA, Dambuza JA, Davis AJA, Mothle AJA
Wednesday: 23 May 2018
COURT A
47. The National Director of Public Prosecutions (Ex Parte Application)
905/2017 (GP)
Judges: Shongwe ADP, Seriti JA, Swain JA, Plasket AJA, Pillay D AJA
COURT B
48. The Standard Bank of South Africa Ltd v Mlungisi Ratsi July & others
525/2017 (ECM)
Judges: Lewis JA, Wallis JA, Saldulker JA, Mocumie JA Rogers AJA
COURT C
49. The Minister of Police & another v Sipho Zweni
842/2017 (ECP)
Judges: Judges: Ponnan JA, Willis JA, Mbha JA, Makgoka AJA, Hughes AJA
Thursday: 24 May 2018
TAX LAW SEMINAR
Friday: 25 May 2018
COURT A
COURT B
COURT C
Monday: 28 May 2018
COURT A
COURT B
COURT C
Tuesday: 29 May 2018
COURT A
COURT B
COURT C
Wednesday: 30 May 2018
COURT A
COURT B
COURT C
Thursday: 31 May 2018
COURT A
COURT B
COURT C
Court Roll (5)
UnpublishedMAY 2018
Updated: 2018.04.06
Tuesday: 01 May 2018
SHIPPING LAW SEMINAR
Wednesday: 02 May 2018
COURT A
1. President of the Republic of South Africa v Democratic Alliance & others
664/2017 (GP)
Judges: Maya P, Majiedt JA, Dambuza JA, Plasket AJA, Mothle AJA
COURT B
2. Louis Pasteur Hospital Holdings (Pty) Ltd v Bonitas Medical Fund
281/2017 (GP)
Judges: Navsa JA, Seriti JA, Saldulker JA, Makgoka AJA, Schippers AJA
COURT C
3. Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality & 5 others vs T A Thubakgale & 133 others
125/2018 (GP)
Judges: Ponnan JA, Swain JA, Mbha JA, Pillay D AJA, Hughes AJA
Thursday: 03 May 2018
COURT A
4. Director of Public Prosecutions, Free State v Sello Joseph Mashune
675/17 (FB)
Judges: Lewis JA, Dambuza JA, Rogers AJA
AND
5. The Director of Public Prosecutions: Gauteng Division, Pretoria v Funewer Coaster Hamisi
895/2017 (GP)
Judges: Lewis JA, Dambuza JA, Rogers AJA
COURT B
6. Antony Louis Mostert & others v Simon John Nash & another
604/2017 and 597/2017 (GP)
Judges: Ponnan JA, Wallis JA, Willis JA, Swain JA, Pillay D AJA
COURT C
7. Alfeus Christo Scholtz & others v The State
428/2017, 491/2017, 635/2017 & 636/2017 (NCK)
Judges: Leach JA, Mathopo JA, Van der Merwe JA, Mocumie JA, Mothle AJA
Friday: 04 May 2018
COURT A
8. Siyabonga David Gongqose & others v Minister of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries & others
and
Siyabonga David Gongqose & others v The State & others
1340/2016 and 287/2017(1365/2016) (ECM)
Judges: Maya P, Majiedt JA, Dambuza JA, Plasket AJA, Schippers AJA
COURT B
9. The Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service v K W J Investment Services (Pty) Ltd
466/2017 (Tax Court)
Judges: Navsa JA, Wallis JA, Mbha JA, Davis AJA, Makgoka AJA
COURT C
7. Alfeus Christo Scholtz & others v The State
428/2017, 491/2017, 635/2017 & 636/2017 (NCK)
Judges: Leach JA, Mathopo JA, Van der Merwe JA, Mocumie JA, Mothle AJA
Monday: 07 May 2018
COURT A
10. David Mile Osborne v Mark William Cockin N O & others
549/2017 (ECG)
Judges: Lewis JA, Willis JA, Saldulker JA, Plasket AJA, Hughes AJA
COURT B
11. The Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service v The South African Breweries (Pty) Ltd
442/2017 (GP)
Judges: Ponnan JA, Wallis JA, Dambuza JA, Davis AJA, Rogers AJA
COURT C
12. Premier Attraction 300 CC t/a Premier Security v City of Cape Town
592/2017 (WCC)
Judges: Majiedt JA, Swain JA, Mbha JA, Pillay D AJA, Schippers AJA
Tuesday: 08 May 2018
COURT A
13. Mogale City Local Municipality v Black Tad Investments CC
889/2017 (GJ)
Judges: Shongwe ADP, Mbha JA, Van der Merwe JA, Mocumie JA, Plasket AJA
COURT B
14. Orthotouch Ltd v Jurie Johannes Geldenhuys
1027/2017 (GP)
Judges: Navsa JA, Majiedt JA, Willis JA, Rogers AJA, Schippers AJA
AND
15. Nicolas Georgiou & 5 others v Sharon Ann Vlok & 3 others
1018/2017 (GP)
Judges: Navsa JA, Majiedt JA, Willis JA, Rogers AJA, Schippers AJA
COURT C
16. Novartis AG v Cipla Medpro (Pty) Ltd & another
728/2017 (GP)
Judges: Lewis JA, Ponnan JA, Leach JA, Saldulker JA, Mathopo JA
Wednesday: 09 May 2018
COURT A
17. Morris Material Handling Limited v Morris Material Handling SA (Pty) Ltd & others
829/2017 (GP)
Judges: Maya P, Majiedt JA, Wallis JA, Dambuza JA, Van der Merwe JA
COURT B
18. Douglasdale Dairy (Pty) Ltd & others v Elizabeth Ann Bragge & another 731/2017 (GJ)
Judges: Shongwe ADP, Willis JA, Swain JA, Davis AJA, Hughes AJA
COURT C
19. Earl Flanagan v The Minister of Safety & Security
497/2017 (ECP)
Judges: Lewis JA, Seriti JA, Saldulker JA, Makgoka AJA, Schippers AJA
Thursday: 10 May 2018
COURT A
20. Vasanthi Naidoo v Discovery Life Limited & others
202/2017 (GJ)
Judges: Shongwe ADP, Wallis JA, Mbha JA, Hughes AJA, Schippers AJA
COURT B
21. Jane Erasmus & others v Nelson Mandela Bay Metropolitan Municipality
537/2017 (ECP)
Judges: Navsa JA, Leach JA, Mathopo JA, Mocumie JA, Pillay D AJA
COURT C
22. Zitonix (Pty) Ltd v K2012150042 (South Africa) (Pty) Ltd
290/2017 (WCC)
Judges: Lewis JA, Swain JA, Davis AJA, Mothle AJA, Rogers AJA
Friday: 11 May 2018
COURT A
23. Friedshelf 325 (Pty) Ltd & another v Sizane Betty Mokwena
652/17 (LCC)
Judges: Maya P, Mbha JA, Van der Merwe JA, Mothle AJA, Schippers AJA
COURT B
24. The Executor of the Estate of the late Josephine Tereblanche Gouws (Charmaine Celliers N O) v Magnificent Mile Trading 30 (Pty) Ltd & others
594/2017 (GP)
Judges: Shongwe ADP, Swain JA, Dambuza JA, Plasket AJA, Rogers AJA
COURT C
25. City of Tshwane Metropolitan Municipality v Lombardy Development (Pty) Ltd & others
724/2017 (GP)
Judges: Ponnan JA, Majiedt JA, Seriti JA, Pillay D AJA, Makgoka AJA
Monday: 14 May 2018
COURT A
26. Buffalo City Metropolitan Municipality v Nurcha Development Finance (Pty) Ltd & others
378/2017 (ECE)
Judges: Shongwe ADP, Seriti JA, Willis JA, Rogers AJA, Schippers AJA
COURT B
27. Leon St Leger Bouttell v Road Accident Fund
324/2017 (GP)
Judges: Navsa JA, Majiedt JA, Mbha JA, Plasket AJA, Hughes AJA
COURT C
28. Minister of Defence & another v Bongani Postolie Xulu
337/2017 (GP)
Judges: Lewis JA, Wallis JA, Saldulker JA, Mocumie JA, Pillay D AJA
Tuesday: 15 May 2018
COURT A
29. Ntuntu David Kekana v Road Accident Fund
206/2017 (GP)
Judges: Shongwe ADP, Leach JA, Mbha JA, Pillay D AJA, Mothle AJA
COURT B
30. Lya Louw & others v Ashraf Davids & others
783/2017 (WCC)
Judges: Navsa JA, Swain JA, Davis AJA, Plasket AJA, Rogers AJA
COURT C
31. Magnum Simplex International (Pty) Ltd v The MEC Provincial Treasury, The Provincial Government of Limpopo
556/2017 (GP)
Judges: Lewis JA, Mathopo JA, Hughes AJA
Wednesday: 16 May 2018
COURT A
32. Francois Jean de Villiers & others v The Trustees for the time being of the G J N Trust & others
756/2017 (WCC)
Judges: Shongwe ADP, Seriti JA, Van der Merwe JA, Rogers AJA, Schippers AJA
COURT B
33. The Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service v JM DA Encarnacӓo N O & another
543/17 (GP)
Judges: Navsa JA, Willis JA, Mocumie JA, Davis AJA, Plasket AJA
COURT C
34. The MEC for the Department of Roads and Public Works & another v AGRI Eastern Cape & others
1107/2017 (ECG)
Judges: Ponnan JA, Wallis JA, Swain JA, Dambuza JA, Hughes AJA
Thursday: 17 May 2018
COURT A
35. WDR Earthmoving Enterprises CC & another v The Joe Gqabi District Municipality & others
392/2017 (ECG)
Judges: Navsa JA, Swain JA, Davis AJA, Pillay D AJA, Hughes AJA
COURT B
36. Bruce St.Clair Moor & another v The Tongaat-Hulett Pension Fund & others
518/2017 (KZD)
Judges: Lewis JA, Majiedt JA, Mbha JA, Dambuza JA, Schippers AJA
COURT C
37. Madibeng Local Municipality v Public Investment Corporation Ltd
603/2017 (GP)
Judges: Ponnan JA, Wallis JA, Willis JA, Plasket AJA, Makgoka AJA
Friday: 18 May 2018
COURT A
38. Road Accident Fund v Khathutshelo Gladys Masindi
586/2017 (GJ)
Judges: Shongwe ADP, Majiedt JA, Swain JA, Mocumie JA, Rogers AJA
COURT B
39. Pioneer Foods (Pty) Ltd v Minister of Finance & others
1166/2017 (WCC)
Judges: Ponnan JA, Wallis JA, Dambuza JA, Davis AJA, Mothle AJA
COURT C
40. Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality v Argent Industrial Investments (Pty) Ltd
809/2017 (GJ)
Judges: Leach JA, Seriti JA, Mbha JA, Van der Merwe JA, Makgoka AJA
Monday: 21 May 2018
COURT A
41. Netshimbupfe Fuzani Ernest & another v Mulaudzi Vhangani Cathcart (on behalf of the Netshimbupfe Royal Council) & others
563/2017 (GP)
Judges: Maya P, Dambuza JA, Mathopo JA, Van der Merwe JA, Mothle AJA
COURT B
42. Kennedy Ntsako Shiburi v The State
205/2017 (LP)
Judges: Shongwe ADP, Saldulker JA, Pillay D AJA, Makgoka AJA, Hughes AJA
COURT C
43. The Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service v Char-Trade 117 CC t/a Ace Packaging
776/2017 (Tax Court)
Judges: Navsa JA, Lewis JA, Mbha JA, Davis AJA, Schippers AJA
Tuesday: 22 May 2018
COURT A
44. Jan George Gabriel Stoltz v Prof L J S Steenkamp
127/2017 (GP)
Judges: Shongwe ADP, Majiedt JA, Saldulker JA, Rogers AJA, Schippers AJA
COURT B
45. AFGRI Operations Limited v Dipaleseng Local Municipality
708/2017 (GJ)
Judges: Navsa JA, Leach JA, Wallis JA, Mbha JA, Van der Merwe JA
COURT C
46. Mantis Investment Holdings (Pty) Ltd v Eastern Cape Development Corporation & others
857/2017 (ECP)
Judges: Ponnan JA, Swain JA, Dambuza JA, Davis AJA, Mothle AJA
Wednesday: 23 May 2018
COURT A
47. The National Director of Public Prosecutions (Ex Parte Application)
905/2017 (GP)
Judges: Shongwe ADP, Seriti JA, Swain JA, Plasket AJA, Pillay D AJA
COURT B
48. The Standard Bank of South Africa Ltd v Mlungisi Ratsi July & others
525/2017 (ECM)
Judges: Lewis JA, Wallis JA, Saldulker JA, Mocumie JA, Rogers AJA
COURT C
49. The Minister of Police & another v Sipho Zweni
842/2017 (ECP)
Judges: Judges: Ponnan JA, Willis JA, Mbha JA, Makgoka AJA, Hughes AJA
Thursday: 24 May 2018
TAX LAW SEMINAR
Friday: 25 May 2018
COURT A
COURT B
COURT C
Monday: 28 May 2018
COURT A
COURT B
COURT C
Tuesday: 29 May 2018
COURT A
COURT B
COURT C
Wednesday: 30 May 2018
COURT A
COURT B
COURT C
Thursday: 31 May 2018
COURT A
COURT B
COURT C
- DPP v Plekenpol (333/17) [2017] ZASCA 151 (21 November 2017)
- Umude & others v The State (148/2017) [2017] ZASCA 150 (21 November 2017)
- Qhinga v State (1327/2016) [2017] ZASCA 149 (15 November 2017)
- Botha v S (901/2016) [2017] ZASCA 148 (8 November 2017)
- Smyth v Investec Bank Ltd (674/2016) [2017] ZASCA 147 (26 October 2017)
- Zuma v DA (771/2016); ANDPP V DA (1170/2016) [2017] ZASCA 146 (13 October 2017)
- Hassim Hardware v Fab Tanks (1129/2016) [2017] ZASCA 145 (13 October 2017)
- Passenger Rail Agency of South Africa v Moabelo (1082/2016) [2017] ZASCA 144 (2 October 2017)
Subcategories
KOEN, PETRUS ARNOLUS
Personal:
Matric: Gert Maritz, PMB.
B Com: University of Natal, 1980
LLB: University of Natal, 1982
Professional History:
Candidate Attorney 1985 to 1986
Attorney, Notary Public and Conveyancer: 1987 – 1988
Advocate: 1988 – 2006
Senior Counsel: 1998
Acting judge of the High Court, KZN periodically - 2004 to 2005.
Judge of High Court, KZN: 1 November 2006 to date.
Acting Judge of Appeal, Supreme Court of Appeal: 1 December 2014 – 31 March 2015
Acting Judge of Appeal, Supreme Court of Appeal: 1 December 2019 – 31 May 2020
Acting Judge of Appeal, Supreme Court of Appeal: 1 October 2023 – 30 November 2023
Acting Judge of Appeal Supreme Court of Appeal: 01 April - 31 May 2024, 01 June - 30 September 2024, 01 October - 30 November 2024
Appointed Judge of Supreme Court of Appeal: 01 December 2024 to date
Other Professional Activities:
Part-time lecturer: Contract and Civil Procedure, University of Natal 1990 – 1995
Member of the Law School Board, University of Natal, Pietermaritzburg: 1996
Member of Society of Advocates: 1988 – 2006
Vice Chair of Pietermaritzburg Society of Advocates: 2003 -2004
Chair of Pietermaritzburg Society of Advocates: 2005
Past member of council of Pietermaritzburg Community Chest
